For a softer cookie, ensure your shortening is butter-flavored. Using all butter will result in a crisper cookie. Adjust the cayenne pepper to your preference. For a milder spice, reduce the amount. Store these cookies in an airtight container at room temperature to maintain their soft texture.
Hudson Collins
Jun 14, 2025I love the soft texture. They didn't last long in my house!
Marilou Hills
Mar 14, 2025The cayenne pepper is a game-changer! So good.
Rosina Connelly
Feb 24, 2025I used blackstrap molasses and they were delicious!
Roslyn Mraz
Feb 10, 2025Easy to follow recipe and the cookies turned out perfectly.
Jennie Carter
Jan 31, 2025My family loved these cookies! Will definitely make them again.
Lee Kris
Dec 31, 2024These cookies are amazing! The perfect balance of sweet and spicy.